Some people think you can’t find good pizza unless you’re in New York or Chicago. Well, guess what? Those people are wrong! If you know where to look, good pizza is everywhere – even here in the small towns of Wyoming. Try a slice from each of these 8 restaurants to check them off of your Wyoming pizza bucket list.
- The Burlington Place, Burlington
Facebook / The Burlington Place
Facebook / The Burlington Place The Burlington Place is a small town favorite! This welcoming pizzeria is known for their specialty slices that are made with fresh locally sourced ingredients.
- Big Horn Mercantile, Big Horn
Facebook / Visit Sheridan, WY
Facebook / Big Horn Mercantile The Big Horn Mercantile is a relic of Wyoming’s pioneer days. Today, they’re famous for wood fired pizza that’s sure to make your mouth water.
- Firehouse Pizza, Casper
Google Local / Alan C.
Google Local / Firehouse Pizza Firehouse Pizza specializes in make-your-own pies. If you can dream it up, they’ll make it for you, and fire it up fresh!
- Racca’s Pizzeria Napoletana, Casper
Google Local / Racca’s Pizzeria Napoletana
Google Local / Racca’s Pizzeria Napoletana Racca’s Pizzeria is an Italian restaurant that serves up big, hearty dishes. Pizza is one of the most popular items on the menu, and after one bite, you’ll be convinced it’s among the best in the state.
- Calico Restaurant and Bar, Wilson
Google Local / Raul Espinoza
Facebook / Calico Restaurant and Bar Calico is one of the most beautiful restaurants in Wyoming. Visit this charming cottage to try custom-crafted wood fired pizza that’s sure to delight you.
- The Pizza Place, Lusk
Google Local / NicksFort
TripAdvisor / CallzemlikeICzM The Pizza Place is an icon in Lusk. In fact, many say this pizzeria put Lusk on the map! It’s so important to the town that after it was destroyed by fire, everyone rallied to help rebuild. Their thick crust pizza is so tasty.
- Bella Fuoco Wood Fired Pizza, Cheyenne
Google Local / Bella Fuoco Wood Fired Pizza
Facebook / Bella Fuoco Wood Fired Pizza Bella Fuoco started off as a food truck, and it was so wildly popular that it had to expand! Today, you can find these wood-fired pizzas being cooked at a charming restaurant in Cheyenne.
- R-Deli, Hulett
Tripadvisor / Wyomingpianoman
Tripadvisor / Lenore R. R-Deli is known for making larger-than-life “Jersey Style” sandwiches, and the best New York style pizza in the West. Add this spot to your Wyoming pizza bucket list and you’ll feel like a foodie in no time.
What’s your favorite pizzeria in Wyoming? Did we miss any small town favorites? Tell us in the comments below!
Facebook / The Burlington Place
The Burlington Place is a small town favorite! This welcoming pizzeria is known for their specialty slices that are made with fresh locally sourced ingredients.
Facebook / Visit Sheridan, WY
Facebook / Big Horn Mercantile
The Big Horn Mercantile is a relic of Wyoming’s pioneer days. Today, they’re famous for wood fired pizza that’s sure to make your mouth water.
Google Local / Alan C.
Google Local / Firehouse Pizza
Firehouse Pizza specializes in make-your-own pies. If you can dream it up, they’ll make it for you, and fire it up fresh!
Google Local / Racca’s Pizzeria Napoletana
Racca’s Pizzeria is an Italian restaurant that serves up big, hearty dishes. Pizza is one of the most popular items on the menu, and after one bite, you’ll be convinced it’s among the best in the state.
Google Local / Raul Espinoza
Facebook / Calico Restaurant and Bar
Calico is one of the most beautiful restaurants in Wyoming. Visit this charming cottage to try custom-crafted wood fired pizza that’s sure to delight you.
Google Local / NicksFort
TripAdvisor / CallzemlikeICzM
The Pizza Place is an icon in Lusk. In fact, many say this pizzeria put Lusk on the map! It’s so important to the town that after it was destroyed by fire, everyone rallied to help rebuild. Their thick crust pizza is so tasty.
Google Local / Bella Fuoco Wood Fired Pizza
Facebook / Bella Fuoco Wood Fired Pizza
Bella Fuoco started off as a food truck, and it was so wildly popular that it had to expand! Today, you can find these wood-fired pizzas being cooked at a charming restaurant in Cheyenne.
Tripadvisor / Wyomingpianoman
Tripadvisor / Lenore R.
R-Deli is known for making larger-than-life “Jersey Style” sandwiches, and the best New York style pizza in the West. Add this spot to your Wyoming pizza bucket list and you’ll feel like a foodie in no time.
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
Address: 100 Main St, Burlington, WY 82411, USAAddress: 210 Johnson St, Big Horn, WY 82833, USAAddress: 395 Newport Rd #1, Casper, WY 82609, USAAddress: 430 S Ash St, Casper, WY 82601, USAAddress: 2650 Moose Wilson Rd, Wilson, WY 83014, USAAddress: 214 S Main, Lusk, WY 82225, USAAddress: 2115 Warren Ave, Cheyenne, WY 82001, USAAddress: R - Deli, 116 WY-24, Hulett, WY 82720, USA
