One of the best things about living in Wyoming is that you never quite know where you’ll discover a bit of the Old West. It seems like nearly everywhere we go, our history follows! That’s true for the best pizzeria in Wyoming as well, because it’s located in an old Mercantile that opened in 1882.

Way back in the 1880s, the Big Horn Mercantile served as a letter stop and general store for travelers in Northern Wyoming, near the Big Horn Mountains.

Facebook / Big Horn Mercantile

Now, more than 130 years later, the same mercantile building is home to the best pizzeria in Wyoming.

Facebook / Visit Sheridan WY

Step on in and you’ll feel like you’ve stepped back in time to the old west. There’s always room for another seat at the table here, and you’ll find the friendly service and bright atmosphere as appealing as the food.

Facebook / Big Horn Mercantile

Their pizzas are all hand-made and prepared in their old fashioned wood fired oven, and Big Horn Merc only uses the finest ingredients. Pictured below, you’ll find their Olive Medley pizza, featuring black, green, and kalamata olvies along with red onion and sundried tomato.

Facebook / Big Horn Mercantile

There’s always something new being made here! The Big Horn Specialty, shown here, is made with basil pesto sauce, garlic, bell peppers, onions, pineapple, black olives, feta and mozzarella cheese - plus Mike’s Hot Honey and fresh basil!

Facebook / Big Horn Mercantile

This Sunday Smokey Pie one is made with house alfredo, garlic, Italian sausage, peppadew peppers and a blend of smoked gouda and mozzarella. Then, it’s finished with Verdello smoked balsamic vinegar and fresh basil.

Facebook / Big Horn Mercantile

The Chicken Bacon Ranch pie is a local favorite. Ranch and garlic are topped with chicken, bacon, onion, tomatoes and mozzarella - finished off with ranch and Verdello pizzaolio oil. Yum!

Facebook / Big Horn Mercantile

Of course, you can never go wrong with a classic! Try their cheese pizza or a pepperoni pie for a simple and delicious meal.

Google Local / Ricardo Rosario

You can find out more about the best pizzeria in Wyoming by visiting the Big Horn Mercantile website, here.

Facebook / Big Horn Mercantile

Facebook / Visit Sheridan WY

Google Local / Ricardo Rosario

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.

Address: 210 Johnson St, Big Horn, WY 82833, USA