Here in Buffalo, we’re firm believers of not fixing what isn’t broken, hence why so many of our favorite attractions and restaurants are businesses that have been around for generations upon generations. In the past, we’ve shared with you lists that showcase some of the longest standing restaurants here inside the city, but today we’re going to showcase another historic gem of Erie County that’s more than worth the quick trip it takes to get there.
Easy to find and right on Main Street in Williamsville, Buffalonians have been making their way to this delicious restaurant since back in the days when they would travel by horse-drawn wagons.
The Eagle House Restaurant has been operating in Williamsville since 1827, earning the title of being the oldest restaurant in all of Erie County.
Eagle House Restaurant/Google
Inside the restaurant, you’ll find a formal yet cozy atmosphere waiting for you — made up of dim-lighting and brick fireplaces.
The Eagle House Restaurant/TripAdvisor
As you look around the multi-level restaurant, you’ll spot history hanging all over the walls that will take you back in time.
Christian D/Google
It isn’t just the historic atmosphere though that draws in Buffalonians and Western New Yorkers to Erie County’s oldest establishment.
Prax-Tammy/TripAdvisor
Known for cooking up classic American dishes as well as Western New York favorites, you’ll be able to choose from things like Pizza Logs, French Onion Au Gratin, Welsh Rarebit & Toast Points, Wings, and Beef on Weck.
#EnjoyingRetirement/TripAdvisor
As well as other highly-rated dishes like their famous Chicken Pot Pie, mouthwatering burgers, Beef Wellington in Puff Pastry, and their well-loved Beer Battered Fish Fry. Yum!
Kurt Zechmann/Google
For those who are feeling thirsty, you can also make a stop at the gorgeous bar inside The Eagle Restaurant.
Dianna Laraiso/Google
Every Tuesday, the restaurant even hosts their Craft Draft Tuesdays where you can enjoy specials on 17 taps pouring drinks from local breweries like Ithaca Brewing, Southern Tier Brewery, Ellicottville Brewing, Hamburg Brewery, 12 Gates, and more.
Eagle House Restaurant/Google
Did you realize such a deliciously historic gem was hiding in plain sight less than 12 miles away from Buffalo?
Eagle House Restaurant/Google
If you’ve yet to experience our county’s oldest restaurant, then it’s time you set a date to experience all that The Eagle House Restaurant has to offer.
Google To find out more about dining at The Eagle House Restaurant in Williamsville, click here!
Address: 5578 Main Street, Williamsville, NY, 14221 Hours: Monday through Saturday from 11 a.m. to 10 p.m., and Sunday from 12 p.m. to 9 p.m.
Ready to discover more delicious eats around the Queen City? Then be sure to read about how This Hippie-Themed Restaurant Near Buffalo Is The Grooviest Place To Dine!
Eagle House Restaurant/Google
The Eagle House Restaurant/TripAdvisor
Christian D/Google
Prax-Tammy/TripAdvisor
#EnjoyingRetirement/TripAdvisor
Kurt Zechmann/Google
Dianna Laraiso/Google
To find out more about dining at The Eagle House Restaurant in Williamsville, click here!
Address: 5578 Main Street, Williamsville, NY, 14221 Hours: Monday through Saturday from 11 a.m. to 10 p.m., and Sunday from 12 p.m. to 9 p.m.
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
