Ahh, the chocolate chip cookie. The gooey, warm deliciousness oozing with pockets of rich chocolate. You can’t just find great chocolate chip cookies anywhere. You have to know the right town bakery with the right recipe. In fact, we have one humble little bakery in Florida that might just serve up the best chocolate chip cookies in the state…but you may have to be the judge.

Lucky for Florida residents there are not one, but two chances to snag delicious chocolate chip cookies from Mattheessen’s.

Google Maps

With two locations on Key West’s Duval Street, you’ll be hard pressed to miss a chance to snag some of this dessert deliciousness.

TripAdvisor Pennysmart

Mattheessen’s has been around for quite some time serving up fresh key lime pies, homemade fudge, and all different types of ice cream.

TripAdvisor Food_Junkie911

But perhaps it’s the dense chocolate chip cookies that make this humble little bakery such a popular destination.

TripAdvisor Tracie73

Imagine a gargantuan chocolate chip cookie, weighing in around half a pound, with flavor that will be just as big as their size.

TripAdvisor Walker M.

You can even customize your chocolate chip cookie experience by adding some fresh pecans, macadamia nuts, or more.

Facebook Mattheessen’s

Using only the finest ingredients, you’ll find homemade cookie dough made fresh from scratch every single day.

Facebook Mattheessen’s

Once the dough is made from scratch, each cookie is weighed out in order to measure a half pound of pure heaven on a plate.

TripAdvisor Keziah S.

It’s not uncommon for visitors to Key West to come back around to Mattheessen’s many times during their trip in order to get as many chocolate chip cookies as possible.

Facebook Mattheessen’s

Head on over to Mattheessen’s Bakery in Key West for a chocolate chip cookie experience that you will crave every time you head south in Florida.

Facebook Mattheessen’s

If you’re ready for chocolate chip cookies, then you can head over to Mattheessen’s at one of two locations:

Google Maps

TripAdvisor Pennysmart

TripAdvisor Food_Junkie911

TripAdvisor Tracie73

TripAdvisor Walker M.

Facebook Mattheessen’s

TripAdvisor Keziah S.

419 Duval St., Key West, FL 33040

106 Duval St., Key West, FL 33040

To learn more about the hours of operation, visit the website or Facebook Page. Meanwhile, when you’re in Key West make sure to check out Frita’s Cuban Cafe.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.