Buffalo’s restaurant scene is full of unique eats on every level. From the swankiest spots to the holes-in-the-wall, where you go really depends on your mood. You know what they say: “Eat hard. Stay humble.” When you’re in the mood to eat delicious meals without frills or fuss, head to these nine humble little restaurants around Buffalo that are so worth the visit.
- Ulrich’s Tavern (674 Ellicott Street)
Ulrich’s Tavern - Facebook
Ulrich’s Tavern - Facebook Ulrich’s Tavern is the oldest tavern in Buffalo. Even more impressive than the history of this humble restaurant is its food. Take a seat at Ulrich’s and indulge in authentic German cuisine to see how this restaurant has stood the test of time.
Learn more about Ulrich’s here.
- Ru’s Pierogi (295 Niagara Street)
Ru’s Pierogi - Facebook
Ru’s Pierogi - Facebook Ru’s Pierogi is tucked away on Niagara Street and at this humble restaurant, you can enjoy amazing ingredients tucked into pierogis like you’ve never experienced. Order them fried, steamed, or stuffed to the brim with dessert fillings. Whatever you decide, Ru’s is definitely worth taking a trip to.
- Astreet Meatball Market (23 Allen Street)
Astreet Meatball Market - Facebook
Astreet Meatball Market - Facebook Astreet Meatball Market is the first of its kind in Buffalo. Who doesn’t love a good old-fashioned meatball? This humble restaurant is located on Allen Street. 10/10 would recommend!
Learn more about this amazing meatball market here.
- Joe’s Deli (Several Locations)
Joe’s Deli Buffalo NY - Facebook
Joe’s Deli Buffalo NY - Facebook Joe’s Deli is a Buffalo classic. While it might not look like much, the food at this deli and restaurant is beyond delicious. Sink your teeth into an amazing sandwich and you’ll see what we mean!
- Garage Cafe & Lounge (1127 Hertel Avenue)
Garage Cafe & Lounge - Facebook
Garage Cafe & Lounge - Facebook The Garage Cafe & Lounge is a newbie on the Buffalo restaurant scene, but from what we’ve seen so far, this place has the potential to stick around a while! Just the fact that it’s inside a cool converted garage makes it worth the trip.
- Betty’s (370 Virginia Street)
Roch06 - TripAdvisor
VerdantTrip - TripAdvisor What would a Buffalo breakfast be without Betty’s? We don’t know… and we don’t want to find out. This humble restaurant is a staple in the 716.
- Buffalo Melting Point (244 Allen Street)
Buffalo Melting Point - Facebook
Buffalo Melting Point - Facebook There’s nothing better than a good grilled cheese sandwich, and no one does it better than Buffalo Melting Point. Their menu of gooey, melty cheese sandwiches is jaw-dropping (and drool-inducing).
Learn more about Buffalo Melting Point here.
- Amy’s Place (3234 Main Street)
Terence K - TripAdvisor
Jane B - TripAdvisor One of the things Buffalo does best is ethnic food. Amy’s Place is proof! Don’t judge this humble restaurant on Main Street by its exterior; the food inside is out of this world.
- West Side Bazaar (25 Grant Street)
West Side Bazaar - Facebook
West Side Bazaar - Facebook Speaking of ethnic food… when you’re in the mood to culture your taste buds but can’t decide which cultural cuisine to indulge in, head to the West Side Bazaar. This humble restaurant has an amazing mission and serves up delicious foods from all over the world!
Do you have a favorite Buffalo restaurant with big flavors that has managed to remain humbly under the radar? What should we add to this list? Share your thoughts in the comments below!
Ulrich’s Tavern - Facebook
Ulrich’s Tavern is the oldest tavern in Buffalo. Even more impressive than the history of this humble restaurant is its food. Take a seat at Ulrich’s and indulge in authentic German cuisine to see how this restaurant has stood the test of time.
Learn more about Ulrich’s here.
Ru’s Pierogi - Facebook
Ru’s Pierogi is tucked away on Niagara Street and at this humble restaurant, you can enjoy amazing ingredients tucked into pierogis like you’ve never experienced. Order them fried, steamed, or stuffed to the brim with dessert fillings. Whatever you decide, Ru’s is definitely worth taking a trip to.
Astreet Meatball Market - Facebook
Astreet Meatball Market is the first of its kind in Buffalo. Who doesn’t love a good old-fashioned meatball? This humble restaurant is located on Allen Street. 10/10 would recommend!
Learn more about this amazing meatball market here.
Joe’s Deli Buffalo NY - Facebook
Joe’s Deli is a Buffalo classic. While it might not look like much, the food at this deli and restaurant is beyond delicious. Sink your teeth into an amazing sandwich and you’ll see what we mean!
Garage Cafe & Lounge - Facebook
The Garage Cafe & Lounge is a newbie on the Buffalo restaurant scene, but from what we’ve seen so far, this place has the potential to stick around a while! Just the fact that it’s inside a cool converted garage makes it worth the trip.
Roch06 - TripAdvisor
VerdantTrip - TripAdvisor
What would a Buffalo breakfast be without Betty’s? We don’t know… and we don’t want to find out. This humble restaurant is a staple in the 716.
Buffalo Melting Point - Facebook
There’s nothing better than a good grilled cheese sandwich, and no one does it better than Buffalo Melting Point. Their menu of gooey, melty cheese sandwiches is jaw-dropping (and drool-inducing).
Learn more about Buffalo Melting Point here.
Terence K - TripAdvisor
Jane B - TripAdvisor
One of the things Buffalo does best is ethnic food. Amy’s Place is proof! Don’t judge this humble restaurant on Main Street by its exterior; the food inside is out of this world.
West Side Bazaar - Facebook
Speaking of ethnic food… when you’re in the mood to culture your taste buds but can’t decide which cultural cuisine to indulge in, head to the West Side Bazaar. This humble restaurant has an amazing mission and serves up delicious foods from all over the world!
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
