With fall in the air, you might find yourself craving those special autumn treats that always pop up this time of year. If that sounds like you, check out these six places in Indiana that serve the absolute best pumpkin ice cream in the state.
Forget PSL and get into something a little sweeter that actually has pumpkin in it. Scroll on for more details.
- Fearrin’s Ice Cream & Yogurt Depot
Facebook/Fearrin’s Ice Cream & Yogurt Depot
Facebook/Fearrin’s Ice Cream & Yogurt Depot Known for the best hot caramel pumpkin sundae in the state, this wonderful shop has been in business since 1990 and is still as popular today as it has been in decades past. People can’t resist the nostalgic atmosphere at this old-fashioned-inspired diner.
Address: 95 South Van Buren Street, Nashville, IN, 47448
- Sundaes Homemade Ice Cream
Facebook/Sundaes Homemade Ice Cream
Facebook/Sundaes Homemade Ice Cream In business since 1995, this widely popular ice cream shop makes frozen dairy treats so good that its ice cream is shipped to restaurants all across the Midwest. In addition to pumpkin, apple pie and cinnamon are the seasonal flavors you’ll find this time of year.
Address: 9922 East 79th Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46256
- The Ice Cream Cottage
Facebook/The Ice Cream Cottage
Facebook/The Ice Cream Cottage A local favorite since 1998, this adorable little shop is known for both its savory and sweet delights. The pumpkin ice cream comes in a shake topped with whipped cream and chocolate drizzle, if you like.
Address: 79 North Van Buren Street, Nashville, IN, 47448
- Ullery’s Homemade Ice-Cream
Google/john s
Facebook/Ullery’s Homemade Ice-Cream The best handmade ice cream in the Hoosier State has been coming out of this vintage spot since 1993. There are always at least 18 flavors and 12 toppings to choose from, and this time of year includes a delicious pumpkin variety you won’t want to miss.
Address: 168 Fort Wayne Avenue #3057, Richmond, IN, 47374
- Ivanhoe’s Drive In
Facebook/Ivanhoe’s Drive In
Facebook/Ivanhoe’s Drive In Known as the home of 100 shakes and 100 sundaes, this iconic drive-in adds on one more this time of year. The pumpkin shake is irresistible to those who have tried it, so taste buds beware.
Address: 979 South Main Street, Upland, IN, 46989
- The Chocolate Moose
Facebook/The Chocolate Moose
Facebook/The Chocolate Moose In business since 1933, this classic creamery does sweet and savory dishes that can’t be beat, and the pumpkin ice cream is the same. Try it before it runs out this season.
Address: 405 South Walnut Street, Bloomington, IN, 47401
If you’re looking for more ice cream, check out these 9 shops in Indiana that may give you a brain freeze.
Facebook/Fearrin’s Ice Cream & Yogurt Depot
Known for the best hot caramel pumpkin sundae in the state, this wonderful shop has been in business since 1990 and is still as popular today as it has been in decades past. People can’t resist the nostalgic atmosphere at this old-fashioned-inspired diner.
Address: 95 South Van Buren Street, Nashville, IN, 47448
Facebook/Sundaes Homemade Ice Cream
In business since 1995, this widely popular ice cream shop makes frozen dairy treats so good that its ice cream is shipped to restaurants all across the Midwest. In addition to pumpkin, apple pie and cinnamon are the seasonal flavors you’ll find this time of year.
Address: 9922 East 79th Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46256
Facebook/The Ice Cream Cottage
A local favorite since 1998, this adorable little shop is known for both its savory and sweet delights. The pumpkin ice cream comes in a shake topped with whipped cream and chocolate drizzle, if you like.
Address: 79 North Van Buren Street, Nashville, IN, 47448
Google/john s
Facebook/Ullery’s Homemade Ice-Cream
The best handmade ice cream in the Hoosier State has been coming out of this vintage spot since 1993. There are always at least 18 flavors and 12 toppings to choose from, and this time of year includes a delicious pumpkin variety you won’t want to miss.
Address: 168 Fort Wayne Avenue #3057, Richmond, IN, 47374
Facebook/Ivanhoe’s Drive In
Known as the home of 100 shakes and 100 sundaes, this iconic drive-in adds on one more this time of year. The pumpkin shake is irresistible to those who have tried it, so taste buds beware.
Address: 979 South Main Street, Upland, IN, 46989
Facebook/The Chocolate Moose
In business since 1933, this classic creamery does sweet and savory dishes that can’t be beat, and the pumpkin ice cream is the same. Try it before it runs out this season.
Address: 405 South Walnut Street, Bloomington, IN, 47401
Where else in Indiana can you get the best pumpkin ice cream? Share your favorite places with us below in the comments.
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
Address: 95 S Van Buren St, Nashville, IN 47448, USAAddress: 9922 E 79th St, Indianapolis, IN 46256, USAAddress: 79 N Van Buren St, Nashville, IN 47448, USAAddress: 979 S Main St, Upland, IN 46989, USAAddress: 405 S Walnut St, Bloomington, IN 47401, USA
