Indiana is a great place for pizzerias, and there are some great ones hiding in tiny towns. These five small town pizza joints are the best of the best and are worth a drive from anywhere in the state. Check ’em out:
- Carolyn’s Country Pizza-Ria - Gentryville
Google/Patrick Gray
Facebook/Carolyn’s Country Pizza-Ria This remote pizzeria is known for its pizza, but it is also known for its fried chicken, burgers, pastas, soups, and much more. You’ll also find cheesecakes, homemade pies, and other desserts that can’t be resisted. Click here to learn more about this place.
- Perillo’s Pizza - North Salem
Facebook/Perillo’s Pizzeria
Facebook/Perillo’s Pizzeria This place has stuffed pizzas, tiramisu, thin-crust, and so much more. Tucked away in a white brick building that used to be a doctor’s office, this cozy eatery is one to visit. Get more details about this pizzeria here.
- Sir Dano’s Pizza Parlor - Sellersburg
Google/Trisha Schmidt
Facebook/Sir Dano’s Pizza Parlor This wonderful restaurant includes a game room and is fun for the whole family. Guests enjoy the pizza buffet as well as the wide variety of appetizers such as pretzels, breadsticks, wings, pasta, and more. Check out more menu items and details about this restaurant here.
- Tomato Pie Pizza Joint - Paragon
Google/Mary
Facebook/Tomato Pie Pizza Joint This wonderful eatery is all around cozy. From the individual pies to the brick exterior, this is a local favorite that can’t be beat. Guests also love the twisted garlic breadsticks as well as the calzones, both of which are made from the same homemade dough as the pizza. Learn more about this wonderful eatery here.
- Pizza, Subs & BBQ - St. Joe
Google/James Fox Podcast
Facebook/PIZZA SUBS & BBQ The homemade food at this incredible restaurant makes it one of the best small town pizza joints in northeast Indiana. In addition to wonderful toppings, you’ll also find menu items like wings, calzones, breadsticks, mozzarella sticks, and cheese curds. Get more details about this popular restaurant here.
For more pizza places in Indiana, check out this bucket list of the best pizzerias in the state.
Google/Patrick Gray
Facebook/Carolyn’s Country Pizza-Ria
This remote pizzeria is known for its pizza, but it is also known for its fried chicken, burgers, pastas, soups, and much more. You’ll also find cheesecakes, homemade pies, and other desserts that can’t be resisted. Click here to learn more about this place.
Facebook/Perillo’s Pizzeria
This place has stuffed pizzas, tiramisu, thin-crust, and so much more. Tucked away in a white brick building that used to be a doctor’s office, this cozy eatery is one to visit. Get more details about this pizzeria here.
Google/Trisha Schmidt
Facebook/Sir Dano’s Pizza Parlor
This wonderful restaurant includes a game room and is fun for the whole family. Guests enjoy the pizza buffet as well as the wide variety of appetizers such as pretzels, breadsticks, wings, pasta, and more. Check out more menu items and details about this restaurant here.
Google/Mary
Facebook/Tomato Pie Pizza Joint
This wonderful eatery is all around cozy. From the individual pies to the brick exterior, this is a local favorite that can’t be beat. Guests also love the twisted garlic breadsticks as well as the calzones, both of which are made from the same homemade dough as the pizza. Learn more about this wonderful eatery here.
Google/James Fox Podcast
Facebook/PIZZA SUBS & BBQ
The homemade food at this incredible restaurant makes it one of the best small town pizza joints in northeast Indiana. In addition to wonderful toppings, you’ll also find menu items like wings, calzones, breadsticks, mozzarella sticks, and cheese curds. Get more details about this popular restaurant here.
What other small town pizza joints do you adore? Share your favorites with us below in the comments.
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
Address: 6788 IN-161, Gentryville, IN 47537, USAAddress: 5 S Broadway St, North Salem, IN 46165, USAAddress: 496 N Indiana Ave, Sellersburg, IN 47172, USAAddress: 100 Union St, Paragon, IN 46166, USAAddress: 519 Washington St, St Joe, IN 46785, USA
